The lawsuit seeks to strike down the American soccer pyramid under antitrust provisions, reinstating NASL Division II status. NASL lost attempts for an preliminary injunction that would have allowed it to play as a Division II league in 2018. Since then, several NASL teams have folded or jumped to Division II USL, leaving just three teams — New York Cosmos, Jacksonville Armada and Miami FC — as going concerns, participating in the 2018 National Premier Soccer League season.
In a press release from NASL, league officials said this: “In answering the complaint, the USSF and MLS both declined the opportunity to file a motion to dismiss.” And here is a statement from Interim Commissioner Rishi Sehgal:
“This clears the path for the NASL to obtain the discovery to prove our claims. Getting discovery from both the USSF and MLS is a critical point in the litigation process. Indeed, the USSF concedes in its answer that if the NASL can prove its allegations, we will have presented a valid claim against the USSF’s use of Professional League Standards to eliminate competition to MLS.”
In terms of courtroom proceedings, not filing a motion to dismiss is not unusual. Motions to dismiss, which come before discovery, tend to procedural in nature (addressing things like whether the complaint was filed in the correct venue, incorrect process serving, etc.) and don’t usually address the original claims in any depth. They are rarely filed and rarely granted, and it would have been highly unusual for MLS and USSF to have filed one, according to the lawyers we consulted for this article. A motion for summary judgment, which comes after discovery, addresses the issues raised in discovery, with the basic argument being that even when presented the most positive light for the plaintiff, there’s no way the plaintiffs can prevail in court. Motion for summary judgment are frequently filed, and it’s not uncommon for a defendant to prevail at that time.
Image courtesy NASL.
RELATED STORIES: NASL Adds MLS to USSF Lawsuit; NASL Scraps 2018 Season; Three Teams to NASL; NASL Appeal of USSF Demotion Denied; Legal Battle Between NASL, U.S. Soccer Intensifies; Jacksonville Armada Shifts to NPSL, But Doesn’t Quit NASL; NASL Moves to International Soccer Calendar; Best of 2017, #2: Trials and Tribulations of NASL; NASL Appeal to be Heard Friday; Miami FC in Limbo as Decision on NASL Awaits; Bad News for NASL: Deltas, FC Edmonton Close Shop; North Carolina FC Departs NASL for USL; Palmer: Jacksonville Armada Without a League; San Francisco Deltas Uncertain for 2018; NASL to Appeal Legal Defeat on 2018 Division II Status; NASL Lawsuit Fails to Retain Division II Status for 2018; NASL Preliminary Injunction Hearing Set for Tuesday; NASL Lawsuit Alleges That SUM Tried to Shut Down Cosmos; Commisso Blasts US Soccer’s Gulati, Calls for Resignation; NASL Calls for Preliminary Injunction to Survive; NASL Lawsuit Challenges US Soccer Over Loss of Division II Status; USSF Will Not Extend NASL’s Division II Status into 2018